Why not trade Smoot for Plummer?

**misdemeanor** · 01-09-2007, 09:37 PM

Plummer would be ok solid QB let Jackson get more experience and work.
No way in the world will smoot go for that much.
My god the guy got burned like a match stick in most if not all the games he played in.
Can't see him being that valuable to many teams.

**LuckyVike** · 01-09-2007, 09:43 PM

"Vikestand" wrote:

Believe it...we need a QB....TJ is not going to be our future...

Yea, since Plummer is so good.
It's not like he has ever lost his job to a rookie.

**nailscoop55** · 01-09-2007, 09:52 PM

"vikinginvirginia" wrote:

How do you already know that TJ is not the future?

How do you know that he is..... I know that he is a rookie and his WR are awful but i still
think he could of perfomed a little bit better

Game 1 stats vs NYJ 14/23-177 1 Td 1 pick 30 rush yards......was terrible at managing the clock and it seemed as though the whole offense was confused on those drives when they were running the quick O

Game 2 Stats vs GB 10/20-50 0 Td 1 pick and 23 rush yards...... he had no pocket presence and looked a little out of his league

Game 3 Stats vs STL 20/34-213 1 Td 1 pick and 34 rush yards....... I know people will say that first pick was a rookie mistake but I dont care if you are NFL, high school, college, or pop warner you do not make that throw bartell for the rams was standing right in front of are reciever when he threw it.

In closing I believe he has potential to be great, he has a rocket arm and great young legs and I think he wants to succed and if he gets the proper coaching and put the right system guys around him he will do well in this league but iam afraid he is going to need a lot of help

**tb04512** · 01-09-2007, 09:54 PM

why not lets see cuz well plummer is G-A-R-B-A-G-E

**vikinginvirginia** · 01-09-2007, 09:59 PM

I don't know that he is. But as you said:

In closing I believe he has potential to be great, he has a rocket arm and great young legs and I think he wants to succed and if he gets the proper coaching and put the right system guys around him he will do well in this league but iam afraid he is going to need a lot of help
[/quote]

Give the kid a chance.

**VikesfaninWis** · 01-09-2007, 10:33 PM

We need WR help right now more then anything.. I like the idea of trading Smoot for Porter at this moment in time..

**idahovikefan7** · 01-09-2007, 10:43 PM

I would love to see plummer come into Minny. I think he still has it in him, and the broncos benched him too early. He's smart and still a little mobile. I would like to see him and porter to come in but it wont happen

.

**Prophet** · 01-10-2007, 12:05 AM

"nailscoop55" wrote:

Game 3 Stats vs STL 20/34-213 1 Td 1 pick and 34 rush yards....... I know people will say that first pick was a rookie mistake but I dont care if you are NFL, high school, college, or pop warner you do not make that throw bartell for the rams was standing ...

I had a perfect angle on that pass, you could see before he released the ball that it was going to be a pick.

Hopefully he'll come a long way in the offseason.
I think it would be wise to let him develop a little more before deeming him the starter.

**vikings_fan66** · 01-10-2007, 12:18 AM

"VikesfaninWis" wrote:

We need WR help right now more then anything.. I like the idea of trading Smoot for Porter at this moment in time..

Ya we do badly need wr help im just not really sold on porter.....obviously better than what we have just dont like his attitude and always thought he has been a tad bit overrated...but i dunno i have never followed him too closely so ill let the paid professionals of the vikings make the call

**ultravikingfan** · 01-10-2007, 04:05 AM

"Potus2028" wrote:

heck yes!

well, i dont know about trading smoot for him

but i would like to add plummer to our roster. dont get me wrong, i like TJack, but i think plummer is better

Plummer got beat by a rookie this year.