Thread: WTF? ESPN QB poll

http://proxy.espn.go.com/chat/sportsnation/listranker?id=709

Bssically you get to rank the top QB's from 1-32 in the league based on who is predicted to start. T-Jack is ranked 32 behind Frye,Leftwhich, Losman, Grossman and Culpepper Farve is currently #6.

WTF Cullpepper? I expexted probaly bottom 10 just because he is still an unknown, But last and behind Culpepper?


1Manning
2Brady
3Brees
4Palmer
5McNabb
6Favre
7Hasselbeck
8Rivers
9Bulger
10Young
11Roethlisberger
12McNair
13Vick
14Romo
15Pennington
16Delhomme
17Green
18E. Manning
19Leinart
20Cutler
21Garcia
22A. Smith
23Leftwich
24Kitna
25Schaub
26Culpepper
27Brunell
28Grossman
29Losman
30Russell
31Frye
32T-Jack

Wow, that's funny. It could be a long season.

A quick glance at the list and I would put him last.
Nobody knows him and he is greener than Gazoo.
He has been deemed the messiah by some, so he will rise.

A quick glance at the list and I would put him last.
Nobody knows him and he is greener than Gazoo.
He has been deemed the messiah by some, so he will rise.

Nice one prophet.
I sure hope some are correct.
The more and more I think about the QB situation I find myself more and more nervous.
Not that I don't support TJ but I like many others have barely seen him play.
Hard not to put him on the bottom of the list at this point.
Hopefully half way through the season he will be in the mudded middle.

I don't see how Grossman is better than T-Jack.
I understand that we haven't seen much of T-Jack and it's a wait and see approach but I have seen plenty of Grossman and there's no way in hell I would want that as my starting QB.
The old ball coach from Florida had lots of great players that were stars in his system in college but failed in the pros.
From what I remember, his system didn't fly very well for the Redskins either.
My point is that I would still rather have a young unproven QB than one who has been on the roster for three years and is unproven.
Also with this logic, how does Russell beat out T-Jack.
I know Russell has awesome physical skills but has not thrown ONE pass in the NFL and wasn't that highly touted until this past season.

"swannyb" wrote:

I don't see how Grossman is better than T-Jack.
I understand that we haven't seen much of T-Jack and it's a wait and see approach but I have seen plenty of Grossman and there's no way in hell I would want that as my starting QB.
The old ball coach from Florida had lots of great players that were stars in his system in college but failed in the pros.
From what I remember, his system didn't fly very well for the Redskins either.
My point is that I would still rather have a young unproven QB than one who has been on the roster for three years and is unproven.
Also with this logic, how does Russell beat out T-Jack.
I know Russell has awesome physical skills but has not thrown ONE pass in the NFL and wasn't that highly touted until this past season.

Ill give you that he should maybe be ranked ahead of Russell for now, but not Grossman. I support T Jack as well, but Grossman led his team to a Super Bowl, T Jack has started 2 NFL games, theres definitley a difference there.

no way is young number 10, pennington is far better than young and he's number 16?!?... i dont see how russell is ahead of TJ, it doesnt suprise me that he is on the bottom no one really knows who he is they only saw him play a couple times, but at the end of the season they will know who he is!!!!

I don't mind seeing Jackson at 32, he is still an unknown, but Farve is only at 6 because of his history.
If you take the past few seasons into account, he should be placed around the 12-15 mark.
As for Culpepper, the list is for QB's who are predicted to start.
I don't think Culpepper will start.

"Prophet" wrote:

A quick glance at the list and I would put him last.
Nobody knows him and he is greener than Gazoo.
He has been deemed the messiah by some, so he will rise.

Culpepper may be done forever, Frye was so great that the Browns made a huge trade into the first round to get Quinn, Russell has not even thrown a pass and he playes for the Raiders.

Quinn should start from game 1 on. Frye is worthless, give the rook a chance!