Re: WOW, I cannot type so good so i's use all caps
Bradshaw....4 rings, Favre...one...'nuff said.
Bradshaw and Tarkenton were NOT better QB's than Favre. Young maybe
I personally have to say Joe Montana. Marino has the records, but Montana has the Super Bowl wins.
my top 5 looks like this...
Favre can move up a spot if he breaks Marinos records, and 2 spots if he wins another Super Bowl
Dream on, Fool! Favre might be a great QB, but he will NOT win another Super Bowl...the Pack doesn't have the defense to do it (which is what really won them the Super Bowl in the 90s)!
Bradshaw, Tarkenton, and Steve Young were all better QBs than Favre...plus all those you listed above Favre. He won't pass any of those either...no matter what he does from here on out...so top 10 is about all he gets...not bad for a hillbilly, though!
Steve Young...definitely more talented...just ask most of the experts...plus if he wouldn't have lost those years to the USFL (and sitting behind Montana), he would have probably had more yardage and TDs than Favre (but not as many INTs...LOL).
Tark...mainly my opinion...but if Tark played in the same era, he would have even more yardage then he did...and could have probably led the 1998 team to a Super Bowl victory.
BANNED OR DEAD...I'LL TAKE EITHER ONE