Vikings All Time Team

Del Rio · 04-13-2006, 01:02 PM

No Grady Alderman?

I would drop Stringer and add Grady in there. Other then that not much to argue.

**ultravikingfan** · 04-13-2006, 01:47 PM

"norseforce" wrote:

wasn't ED WHITE a G? thats a good lineup ULTRA but.... cant you squeeze in MILLARD

White was a Guard, like wes stated above.

Squeeze in Millard? Where? Bump off Page who is a HOF'r and one of the best ever, or Randle who had more sacks in the 90's than anybody else?

I mean, Keith was good...but it was not for a very long time for us.

**ultravikingfan** · 04-13-2006, 01:48 PM

"Del Rio" wrote:

No Grady Alderman?

I would drop Stringer and add Grady in there. Other then that not much to argue.

Good call there. I biffed it on that.

Either way, 2 good Tackles.

Del Rio · 04-13-2006, 01:55 PM

"ultravikingfan" wrote:

"Del Rio" wrote:

No Grady Alderman?

I would drop Stringer and add Grady in there. Other then that not much to argue.

Good call there. I biffed it on that.

Either way, 2 good Tackles.

Yeah well when I made my list you reminded me I left off Randall McDaniel lol, so my goof up was way bigger the yours.

**Freya** · 04-13-2006, 03:02 PM

I'd put in Stu Voight or Joe Senser over Jordan for TE.

Looks good otherwise.....

**Zeus** · 04-13-2006, 03:07 PM

"ultravikingfan" wrote:

"AWZeus" wrote:

"ultravikingfan" wrote:

I really cringe with these type of threads, but I will play:

QB: Fran
RB: Chuck Foreman, Robert Smith
WR: Cris Carter, Randy Moss
TE: Steve Jordan
G: Randall McDaniel, Todd Kalis
T: Korey Stringer, Ron Yary
C: Mike Tiglehoff

DE: Jim Marshall, Carl Ellar
DT: John Randle, Alan Page
LB: Scott Studwell, Matt Blair, Jack Del Rio
DB: Paul Krause, Joey Browner, Bobby Bryant, Ed Sharockman

K: Fred Cox

I like this team - although I have a few minor quibbles:

1. You've got 2 tailbacks. I think you need a fullback to run the classic I-formation. In that case, I'll pick JimmyK.

2. The Korey Stringer pick is emotion. Tim Irwin did it as good for longer.

3. I'm such a huge fan of Antoine Winfield (in particular his tackling ability) that I'm inclined to put him on here, even if it's only after 2 years.

4. At kicker - I'm not sure if Freddie Cox is a better choice than say Fuad Reveiz or Jan Stenerud....tough debate.

5. You don't have a punter! My pick is Mitch Berger.

=Z=

Are you kidding me? This is why I hate threads like this. Jan Stenerud? He played for us for 2 years. Cox was the man from 63-77.

I know I have 2 RB's, I chose it that way because the accomplishments of the RB's are far greater than that of the FB's.

Stringer was good and he was my pick not out of emotion. He was well on his way to be a star.

Winfield could go in there, but but Bryant and Sharockman were nails.

And yes, I did not put a Punter in there. He only asked for atleast 22 players and I gave him Cox as a bonus.

Lets see the rest of your list?

The rest of my list was the same as yours. And my deal on Cox was that I don't recall Freddy having that big of a leg. Accurate to be sure - of course, I could be way wrong (wouldn't be the first time - won't be the last).

=Z=