Page 1 of 6 123 ... LastLast
Results 1 to 10 of 58
  1. #1
    MindFreak's Avatar
    MindFreak is offline Starter
    Join Date
    Jan 2008
    Posts
    205

    Which Viking Roster would you rather have

    Here's a list of rosters from 2 different seasons, please just highlight 1 player from each set for the player you'd rather have.

    Tarvaris Jackson
    Daunte Culpepper

    Moe Williams
    Adrian Peterson

    Randy Moss
    Bobby Wade

    Nate Burleson
    Sidney Rice

    Kelly Campbell
    Robert Ferguson

    D'Wayne Bates
    Troy Willimason

    Jim Kleinsasser
    Visanthe Shiancoe

    Everett Lindsay
    Bryant McKinnie

    Chris Liwienski
    Steve Hutchinson

    David Dixon
    Anthony Herrera

    Mike Rosenthal
    Ryan Cook

    Kevin Williams
    Kenechi Udeze

    Fred Robbins
    Kevin Williams

    Chris Hovan
    Pat Williams

    Kenny Mixon
    Ray Edwards

    Henri Crockett
    Ben Leber

    Greg Biekert
    EJ Henderson

    Chris Claiborne
    Chad Greenway

    Brain Williams
    Antoine Winfield

    Ken Irvin
    Cedric Griffin

    Corey Chavous
    Darren Sharper

    Brain Russell
    Dwight Smith

    Aaron Elling
    Ryan Longwell

    Eddie Johnson
    Chris Kluwe
    You can't be let down if you don't expect the world

  2. #2
    Zeus's Avatar
    Zeus is offline Jersey Retired
    Join Date
    Apr 2006
    Location
    Minnesota.
    Posts
    23,937

    Re: Which Viking Roster would you rather have

    Mine:

    Tarvaris Jackson
    Adrian Peterson
    Randy Moss
    Sidney Rice
    Robert Ferguson
    D'Wayne Bates
    Visanthe Shiancoe
    Bryant McKinnie
    Steve Hutchinson
    David Dixon
    Ryan Cook
    Kenechi Udeze
    Kevin Williams
    Pat Williams
    Ray Edwards
    Ben Leber
    EJ Henderson
    Chris Claiborne
    Antoine Winfield
    Cedric Griffin
    Corey Chavous
    Brian Russell
    Ryan Longwell
    Chris Kluwe

    The team needs a center, however.
    And a FB.

    =Z=

    Thanks to Josdin for the awesome sig!

  3. #3
    Marrdro's Avatar
    Marrdro is offline Beware My Spreadsheet, Bitches!
    Join Date
    Dec 1969
    Posts
    43,935

    Re: Which Viking Roster would you rather have

    Tarvaris Jackson Bigger hands, more upside.
    Seems to be a bit more stable (mentally)
    Daunte Culpepper

    Moe Williams
    Adrian Peterson

    Randy Moss
    Bobby Wade
    I am picking B-wade here cause Randy wouldn't be a good slot guy.
    If you would have matched him up with our outside WR I would have taken him there.

    Nate Burleson
    Sidney Rice
    I would have probably taken Randy over Sidney but Sidney is a better outside/Redzone guy that Nate ever was.

    Kelly Campbell
    Robert Ferguson Hate to say it, but Fergy.

    D'Wayne Bates
    Troy Willimason - Niether.
    I would have a FB or an extra TE in for our base offense.

    Jim Kleinsasser
    Visanthe Shiancoe - Both.
    See comments above

    Everett Lindsay
    Bryant McKinnie
    He still has a hard time with smaller/faster DE's.

    Chris Liwienski
    Steve Hutchinson

    David Dixon
    Anthony Herrera

    Mike Rosenthal
    Ryan Cook His upside is huge.
    I really thought (I'm in the small minority) that he played better than I thought he would last year.

    Kevin Williams
    Kenechi Udeze What position are you talking about.
    I would take Udeze for a LDE

    Fred Robbins
    Kevin Williams I'll take Kevin for my DT

    Chris Hovan
    Pat Williams

    Kenny Mixon
    Ray Edwards

    Henri Crockett
    Ben Leber

    Greg Biekert
    EJ Henderson First tough one.

    Chris Claiborne
    Chad Greenway Chris wouldn't do well in our scheme.

    Brain Williams
    Antoine Winfield

    Ken Irvin
    Cedric Griffin

    Corey Chavous
    Darren Sharper

    Brain Russell
    Dwight Smith Another tough one.
    I like Russell more but think his coverage skills would be a detractor.

    Aaron Elling
    Ryan Longwell

    Eddie Johnson
    Chris Kluwe

    T-Rich.
    Many many thanks to my talented friend Jos for the new Sig.http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v343/josdin00/Vikings/Marrdro_sig.jpg

  4. #4
    purplepowered is offline Pro-Bowler
    Join Date
    Dec 2007
    Posts
    490

    Re: Which Viking Roster would you rather have

    Tarvaris Jackson- Mentality better hands more upside
    Daunte Culpepper

    Moe Williams
    Adrian PetersonDuh nuthing against Moe

    Randy Moss
    Bobby Wade

    Nate Burleson
    Sidney RiceI like Nate now but Sid has made some great catches and i see him as a far better WR in the long run IF we use him correctly

    Kelly Campbell
    Robert Fergusonbecause of experience

    D'Wayne Bates
    Troy Willimason take a pass here cause i dont think eitherr can catch and
    a TE would be better

    Jim Kleinsasser
    Visanthe ShiancoeKliensasser ealier in his career
    we used far more so I dont know and havent seen enought of VS

    Everett Lindsay
    Bryant McKinnie

    Chris Liwienski
    Steve Hutchinson

    David Dixon
    Anthony Herrera

    Mike Rosenthal
    Ryan Cook I would have said Mike at first but Cook came along at the end of the season

    Kevin Williams
    Kenechi Udeze as far as DE

    Fred Robbins
    Kevin Williams DL

    Chris Hovan
    Pat WilliamsDL

    Kenny Mixon
    Ray Edwards Keep off steroids he will be ok

    Henri Crockett
    Ben Leber Leber has been all over this year. I love this guy. Was solid pu for this club.

    Greg Biekert
    EJ Henderson I loved Greg too but EJ has been a mean dog and with a mean streak awesome work this year.

    Chris Claiborne
    Chad Greenway Another one with great work ethic and skills just too bad his year didnt even get started due to coaches decision on sp teams during preseason last year.

    Brain Williams
    Antoine Winfield I like Brian Williams too. miss him greatly but with Antoine we have the best tackling CB in the league here no brainer.

    Ken Irvin
    Cedric Griffin This kid is only going to grow. I see a huge upside although when he gets beat i hate the smiles he has on TDs. So once he can get rid of those I will be happier.

    Corey Chavous
    Darren SharperI like both
    here too. Chavous because he tapes all games and studies all teams desperately and DSharp never slows down shows great poise and mental sharpness.

    Brain Russell
    Dwight Smith I love Smith for the hard hits but not the pot hits, Brian Russel showing him up in Seatlle tho.

    Aaron Elling
    Ryan LongwellHello! NO BRAINER!

    Eddie Johnson
    Chris Kluwe The savior this year. Especially the first 2/3! Thank you! You are a God Send Kluwe! You and AP saved our aZZ

    T-Rich Congrats to ur ProBowl too! TJack You are showing good progress! Get Rice in more! Keep Taylor if we get rid of him we will miss him next year watch!
    I am THE #1 Sidney Rice #18 Fan ever! Don't Be surprised when this kid IS a superstar! He is humble, smart, tough, talented and has alot of character! Takes alot of pride in his work, team, fans and life. Watch out for this kid! I think he is awesome! Everytime he touches the ball its MAGIC!

  5. #5
    marstc09's Avatar
    marstc09 is offline Jersey Retired
    Join Date
    Dec 1969
    Location
    Phoenix, Arizona
    Posts
    23,180

    Re: Which Viking Roster would you rather have

    Tarvaris Jackson
    Daunte Culpepper

    Moe Williams
    Adrian Peterson

    Randy Moss
    Bobby Wade

    Nate Burleson
    Sidney Rice

    Kelly Campbell
    Robert Ferguson

    D'Wayne Bates
    Troy Willimason

    Jim Kleinsasser
    Visanthe Shiancoe

    Everett Lindsay
    Bryant McKinnie

    Chris Liwienski
    Steve Hutchinson

    David Dixon
    Anthony Herrera

    Mike Rosenthal
    Ryan Cook

    Kevin Williams
    Kenechi Udeze

    Fred Robbins
    Kevin Williams

    Chris Hovan
    Pat Williams

    Kenny Mixon
    Ray Edwards

    Henri Crockett
    Ben Leber

    Greg Biekert
    EJ Henderson

    Chris Claiborne
    Chad Greenway

    Brain Williams
    Antoine Winfield

    Ken Irvin
    Cedric Griffin

    Corey Chavous
    Darren Sharper

    Brain Russell
    Dwight Smith

    Aaron Elling
    Ryan Longwell

    Eddie Johnson
    Chris Kluwe

  6. #6
    Garland Greene's Avatar
    Garland Greene is offline Jersey Retired
    Join Date
    Aug 2006
    Location
    A, A
    Posts
    6,170

    Re: Which Viking Roster would you rather have

    Tarvaris Jackson
    Daunte Culpepper

    Moe Williams
    Adrian Peterson

    Randy Moss
    Bobby Wade

    Nate Burleson
    Sidney Rice

    Kelly Campbell
    Robert Ferguson

    D'Wayne Bates
    Troy Willimason

    Jim Kleinsasser
    Visanthe Shiancoe

    Everett Lindsay
    Bryant McKinnie

    Chris Liwienski
    Steve Hutchinson

    David Dixon
    Anthony Herrera

    Mike Rosenthal
    Ryan Cook

    Kevin Williams
    Kenechi Udeze

    Fred Robbins
    Kevin Williams

    Chris Hovan
    Pat Williams

    Kenny Mixon
    Ray Edwards

    Henri Crockett
    Ben Leber

    Greg Biekert
    EJ Henderson

    Chris Claiborne
    Chad Greenway

    Brain Williams
    Antoine Winfield

    Ken Irvin
    Cedric Griffin

    Corey Chavous
    Darren Sharper

    Brain Russell
    Dwight Smith

    Aaron Elling
    Ryan Longwell

    Eddie Johnson
    Chris Kluwe

  7. #7
    KrackerJack's Avatar
    KrackerJack is offline Hall of Famer
    Join Date
    Sep 2006
    Posts
    1,502

    Re: Which Viking Roster would you rather have

    Tarvaris Jackson
    Daunte Culpepper

    Moe Williams
    Adrian Peterson

    Randy Moss
    Bobby Wade

    Nate Burleson
    Sidney Rice

    Kelly Campbell
    Robert Ferguson

    D'Wayne Bates
    Troy Willimason

    Jim Kleinsasser
    Visanthe Shiancoe

    Everett Lindsay
    Bryant McKinnie

    Chris Liwienski
    Steve Hutchinson

    David Dixon
    Anthony Herrera

    Mike Rosenthal
    Ryan Cook

    Kevin Williams
    Kenechi Udeze

    Fred Robbins
    Kevin Williams

    Chris Hovan
    Pat Williams

    Kenny Mixon
    Ray Edwards

    Henri Crockett
    Ben Leber

    Greg Biekert
    EJ Henderson

    Chris Claiborne
    Chad Greenway

    Brain Williams
    Antoine Winfield

    Ken Irvin
    Cedric Griffin

    Corey Chavous
    Darren Sharper

    Briann Russell
    Dwight Smith don't remember how good Russell was...just take Dwight despite off the field

    Aaron Elling
    Ryan Longwell

    Eddie Johnson
    Chris Kluwe


    like most of our current roster, with a couple exceptions

  8. #8
    Mr Anderson's Avatar
    Mr Anderson is offline Jersey Retired
    Join Date
    Dec 1969
    Posts
    7,692

    Re: Which Viking Roster would you rather have

    Tarvaris Jackson
    Daunte Culpepper

    Moe Williams
    Adrian Peterson

    Randy Moss
    Bobby Wade

    Nate Burleson
    Sidney Rice

    Kelly Campbell
    Robert Ferguson

    D'Wayne Bates
    Troy Willimason

    Jim Kleinsasser
    Visanthe Shiancoe
    (We have them both on this roster)

    Everett Lindsay
    Bryant McKinnie

    Chris Liwienski
    Steve Hutchinson

    David Dixon

    Anthony Herrera

    Mike Rosenthal
    Ryan Cook

    this is truly the hardest decision I've ever made in my life. These are the two names I've cursed more














    than any other in my football watching career. But Cook is improving.

    Kevin Williams
    Kenechi Udeze(both on this roster)

    Fred Robbins
    Kevin Williams(can't have him twice)

    Chris Hovan
    Pat Williams

    Kenny Mixon
    Ray Edwards

    Henri Crockett
    Ben Leber

    Greg Biekert
    EJ Henderson

    Chris Claiborne
    Chad Greenway (Man we had some shitty linebackers in the past)

    Brain Williams
    Antoine Winfield

    Ken Irvin
    Cedric Griffin

    Corey Chavous
    Darren Sharper

    Brain Russell
    Dwight Smith

    Aaron Elling
    Ryan Longwell

    Eddie Johnson
    Chris Kluwe



    Basically, this year's team, plus one o-lineman and Randy Moss.

  9. #9
    Join Date
    Dec 1969
    Posts
    1,206

    Re: Which Viking Roster would you rather have

    I've got most of these the same as everyone else, so I won't list them all.
    But I've got a few different ones that people have gone other ways on:

    Daunte Culpepper - Headcase?
    Yes.
    Good player in his prime?
    Yes.
    I'm assuming we're talking about an entire career, and not just where they are now though.
    While I don't think Culpepper is done, Jackson's future is much brighter at this point.
    But there's a real chance that Jackson is out of the league in three years - without the stats, Pro Bowls, or playoff appearances that Daunte had here.

    Brian Russell - He was a very good safety for us, and is still a pretty good safety for Seattle.
    Dwight has been okay, but I'm down on the guy right now and expect him to be cut.

    Ryan Cook - I'm not impressed with him so far, but someone said he graded out as the 11th best RT in the league (still wondering where this stat came from?).
    He at least has some potential, while Rosenthal was at best an average RT for a few years.

    "Marrdro" wrote:
    Randy Moss
    Bobby Wade
    I am picking B-wade here cause Randy wouldn't be a good slot guy.
    If you would have matched him up with our outside WR I would have taken him there.
    Wow, there goes all your credibility.
    8,866 posts right down the drain (just kidding... mostly).
    Way to speak your mind though.
    When the age of the Vikings came to a close, they must have sensed it. Probably, they gathered together one evening, slapped each other on the back and said, "Hey, good job." - Jack Handey [Deep Thoughts]

  10. #10
    Garland Greene's Avatar
    Garland Greene is offline Jersey Retired
    Join Date
    Aug 2006
    Location
    A, A
    Posts
    6,170

    Re: Which Viking Roster would you rather have

    "Overlord" wrote:
    I've got most of these the same as everyone else, so I won't list them all.
    But I've got a few different ones that people have gone other ways on:

    Daunte Culpepper - Headcase?
    Yes.
    Good player in his prime?
    Yes.
    I'm assuming we're talking about an entire career, and not just where they are now though.
    While I don't think Culpepper is done, Jackson's future is much brighter at this point.
    But there's a real chance that Jackson is out of the league in three years - without the stats, Pro Bowls, or playoff appearances that Daunte had here.

    Brian Russell - He was a very good safety for us, and is still a pretty good safety for Seattle.
    Dwight has been okay, but I'm down on the guy right now and expect him to be cut.

    Ryan Cook - I'm not impressed with him so far, but someone said he graded out as the 11th best RT in the league (still wondering where this stat came from?).
    He at least has some potential, while Rosenthal was at best an average RT for a few years.

    "Marrdro" wrote:
    Randy Moss
    Bobby Wade
    I am picking B-wade here cause Randy wouldn't be a good slot guy.
    If you would have matched him up with our outside WR I would have taken him there.
    Wow, there goes all your credibility.
    8,866 posts right down the drain (just kidding... mostly).
    Way to speak your mind though.
    I have to agree with Marr on that one. I picked Biekert only because up until I would say this year, some argument to last year that EJ finally is playing like a very good MLB. I rememebr when he was considered almost on the same level that Williamson is now. Nothing wrong with EJ but i see beikert as more of the leader that may be missing from EJ. just my 2 cents on it. There were also a couple that were a complete toss up. griffith?irvin, Bates/Williamson.

Page 1 of 6 123 ... LastLast

Similar Threads

  1. Marrdro's 2009 Roster Analysis - (53 Man Roster Finalized - How did I do?)
    By Marrdro in forum Vikings Offseason/Draft/FA Forum
    Replies: 169
    Last Post: 09-06-2009, 11:22 AM
  2. Marrdro's Roster Analysis (New Roster Analysis Added)
    By Marrdro in forum Vikings Offseason/Draft/FA Forum
    Replies: 101
    Last Post: 05-02-2008, 07:27 PM
  3. post your roster
    By YogidAbEAR in forum Fantasy Football Talk
    Replies: 32
    Last Post: 11-08-2006, 10:55 AM
  4. K-Fan Predicts 53-Man roster
    By Vikes_King in forum Vikings Fan Forum
    Replies: 0
    Last Post: 08-31-2006, 05:36 PM
  5. The new MVC roster
    By RK. in forum Vikings Fan Forum
    Replies: 21
    Last Post: 04-29-2005, 09:20 PM

Tags for this Thread

Bookmarks

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •