SI Players' Poll on QBs

**LosAngelis** · 09-22-2004, 09:59 PM

[Based on a survey of 354 current and former players. Players were not allowed to vote for a QB on their team.]

Who is the NFL's best quarterback?

Peyton Manning ...... 34%
Brett Favre .............. 23%
Tom Brady ................ 14%
Steve McNair ........... 12%
Michael Vick .............. 8%
Donovan McNabb ..... 5%
Daunte Culpepper .... 1%

Which QB is most dangerous in a fourth-quarter comeback?

Brett Favre ....................... 47%
Tom Brady ......................... 15%
Peyton Manning ............... 15%
Michael Vick ..................... 10%
Steve McNair ...................... 7%
Donovan McNabb ............... 4%
Jake Delhomme .................. 2%

**vikings minnesoulija** · 09-22-2004, 10:01 PM

Vick better then DC? Farve most dangerous in the fourth quater yeah in the regular season.

**packmanxxxi** · 09-22-2004, 10:09 PM

Interesting results... have to say I agree 100%... and this is from the players... somehow I think they would know more than all of us...

**cajunvike** · 09-22-2004, 10:38 PM

Except that McCrab is not better than Pep. Just more buying into the media bias towards DMcC again.

**VikingsTw** · 09-22-2004, 11:36 PM

If Daunte had the power to be a great come back QB he would be up there with the big dogs, I still think hes better than McNabb. He really needs to work on his come back ability because he has never really shown me that. I hate to get behind because Pepp always has a hard time diging his way out of a whole. Lets hope he improves on that.

**cajunvike** · 09-22-2004, 11:41 PM

True that.

**vikings minnesoulija** · 09-22-2004, 11:44 PM

Farve gets love still and he is not very good anymore, look at his past playoff games, and answer why would anybody want him to lead a comback, he chokes when it counts.

**cajunvike** · 09-23-2004, 12:00 AM

That is what I like about you, soulija. You lay it on the line and pull no punches. Too bad the Vikes offense doesn't have more of that attitude (i.e., run the ball down other defenses' throats with that monster offensive line). OLs love nothing more than to run over people and hate nothing more than to have to pass block against bullrushing DLs.

**whackthepack** · 09-23-2004, 08:58 AM

"packmanxxxi" wrote:

Interesting results... have to say I agree 100%... and this is from the players... somehow I think they would know more than all of us...

What a surprise that you would agree Packmann, if Farve wasn't on this list you would be making up some excuse why the poll is not valid.

We will see were the numbers and were the standing fall at the end of the year and decide than who is the biggest threat.

In Probowls not all the best palyers are on the field, a lot of times it is given to players that do not deserve it anymore!!!!