Thread: Favre for 1 year or McNabb for 3-4 years?

What would you rather have Favre for next year or McNabb for the next few years? Im pretty sure teh core of this team is locked up until 2013, so i'd rather have Donovan. What Ya Think?

Ok...well I still am not sold on Mcnabb.Sorry, on top of that I have a feeling that unless every effort possible has been made to get Favre back on board next year, I believe it will be a bit of a "hard row" for Mcnabb or anyone else other than TJ. Meaning Favre won this team over soooo completely and they seem to all want him back so bad that...well those are some mighty big shoes to fill. So I have to say Favre. Besides there are already rumors flying about Mcnabb to Arizona.

ChesterTheMolester wrote:

What would you rather have Favre for next year or McNabb for the next few years? Im pretty sure teh core of this team is locked up until 2013, so i'd rather have Donovan. What Ya Think?

If McNabb comes here . . . I am gone from the fan ranks. Never liked him. Never will. A player with no charisma, no sparkle, no excitement.

My lasting impression of him will be coming out of the visitors locker room in Dallas when he "attacked" the partition and tried to scare the fans. What a thug. Too bad there isn't room for him with the Saints. Perfect fit.

P.S. If my Brett does indeed retire, the next QB here is going to face a tall order. For the first time in a long while (IMHO EVER!) the Vikes had a real star onboard, a player with zest and verve and excitment and passion that transmitted directly to the fans.

purpledoom wrote:

Ok...well I still am not sold on Mcnabb.Sorry, on top of that I have a feeling that unless every effort possible has been made to get Favre back on board next year, I believe it will be a bit of a "hard row" for Mcnabb or anyone else other than TJ. Meaning Favre won this team over soooo completely and they seem to all want him back so bad that...well those are some mighty big shoes to fill. So I have to say Favre. Besides there are already rumors flying about Mcnabb to Arizona.

rightonrightonrightonrightonrightonrighton!

I can barely believe that I am going to say this but.........

Favre for one.

Ouch. :blink:

Id be happy with both. Win now Baby!!!! (Favre over Donovan)

*Meaning no TJack or Sage

Favre for one season, no questions asked.

Favre no doubt about it

McNabb EASILY...EASILY

Favre for 2!! Wishful thinking...ok for one.