Rewatch the game
Sometimes the ball was not thrown but he was out of position
And sometimes it was and the WRs flat out dropped the ball
He did make a few tips and cut off some slants.. But he was getting shook on routes all night
Yeah I'll probably rewatch the game at some point just because it was a great game but I doubt you will confince me he was getting shook all night but I'll check to see "What Is". I saw one pass that Davis dropped, that route and throw can be very difficult for any corner to cover, the only problem was it was a inch or two from being a perfect pass, a very hard one to defend.
The biggest issue Winfield had last night was the one
play he did give up, which was a slant pass to Hester then a wiffed tackle. Winfield has been beaten by a few WR's with Elite speed such as Devin Hester, Chad Johnson, Donald Driver and Bernard Berrian. He can struggle with Elite speed but more often that not he's winning.
If in deed he was "shook all night" and "out of position" its uncharacteristic.