Thread: CONGRATS DAUNTE!!!

Since when did football become a QB-only game? His record is bad, but oh wait, maybe its because he's playing with possibly the lousiest defence in history of NFL?

DC has gotten his props this year from anouncers and fans alike. It may not be as much as McNabb but it is for different reasons.

McNabb, if on an under achieving team, would be in the same situation as DC.

DC has had an awesome year and it is unfortunate for him we didn't provide him with some more wins. It is also unfortunate that he was eclipsed by Manning's deserved success.

"packmanxxxi" wrote:

All im saying is Culpepper is 36-37 all time after todays game....

Im not talking about his skills... his skills are remarkable...

Give him the defenses that Favre has had the privilege to have on his side and then we can talk...many sportswriters felt that Reggie White was the true MVP of the last SB that GB won...not Favre.

well cajum, how about favre going 10-6 each of the last 2 seasons and 12-4 the season before... eventhough he probably had the second worst D in the NFL...

Cully has a better reciever.. a close level RB core... and the same D... Favre has 3 div titles, cully none

You idiot, how are you comparing C-Pep's and Favre titles? How about Favre playing 13 full seasons against Pep's 5?

Im talking about just the last 3 seasons....

Favre has six titles remember... playoffs in 10 of 13 seasons...

keep talking...

"packmanxxxi" wrote:

Pep is a very good QB... I dont know who would argue that... Im just saying that hes not a winner... and you cant argue that either...

How many years was Favre in the league before he started winning?

Just wait his career is not over yet.

And if Elway would not have won a SB (against the Pack) and a second SB (ATL) he wouldn't have been considered a winner.

So if all you are saying is that he is not a winner then you have time to be proven wrong.

When his career is over, he will be on the list of the greatest QBs to play the game.

I can tell you one thing, I am not adding Tom Brady to the list of greatest QBs to play the game just yet (maybe when his career is over). But you can call him a winner if you like. He played the same kind of mistake free football that DC is playing but Brady (Favre also) was fortunate enough to have others step it up around him, Vinatieri, D-fense, and some WR's.

Last three seasons McCrab has owned his division too. Does it make him any better than C-Pep? No. STFU.

All I am saying is:

I didn't know DC retired.

yes, McNabb is better... he wins... PERIOD...

and snow in april... Favre was 9-7 his first year... his worst year was 1999 at 8-8... EVERY other season he has had a winning record, making the playoffs in 10 of 13 years...

Id say he won right away, wouldn't you??