Thread: Comparing Cpep to Vick

Compare them. Falcons fans say Vick is better because he wins, i say if you put the Falcons defense behind Cpep last year and Vikings go 13-3. Compare.

"IbleedPURPLEandGOLD" wrote:

Compare them. Falcons fans say Vick is better because he wins, i say if you put the Falcons defense behind Cpep last year and Vikings go 13-3. Compare.

Hard to compare.

I see them as different type of QB's. Pep can actually have a passing game.

Running- the edge goes to Vick, but probably because he simply has to run more.
Passing- no doubt Pep...when Culpepper is playing normally

last year's numbers pass completion:
Pep 69.5% to Vick's 56.4%
TD:INT Pep's 39:11 versus Vick's 14:12

Yeah, I know, last years' numbers, but the point is the Culpepper is simply a better passer and isn't all that bad on the rush. I'd rather have Pep any day (except for the first two games this year...just kidding).

Pep is way better dude.. Vick can only run.. Pep can run some himself.. And if he gets grabbed he is way harder to take down.. Pep sees the feild better too I think.. Not to take anything away from Vick cuz he is very dangerous and can win a game by himself

Michael isn't even the best Vick.

everybody knows vick can't throw, his dumb little brother can't throw either and people talk about how they are both such good quarterbacks? that doesn't make sence

I believe Cpep is better than Vick...Cpep has size, strenghth, moibility, accuracy and arm power...where Michael has just been built on the premise of media, heisman, and wow he can run and is fast...damn sounds like a WR lol

I must agree Pep is far more poised and experienced as a nfl QB. He might not be as overall athletic as Vick running, but Pep can run, he doesn't have to because he is much more developed as a QB and choses to throw it, but if he needs to he can lower the shoulder and run it the same as Vick or Mcnabb as well.

Mike

Pep seems to be the all-around QB. As far as running goes, hands down, Vick is way better. I know you guys always see the highlights of last years game against us. Vick is just nuts! He has way more moves, and is much faster and elusive than Daunte. Two differnt types of runners. Daunte will get the first and lower his shoulder to punish the tackler. Vick will get the first and the potential to go all the way. If I had to choose one to build my team around, Pep would be the pick.

aloha, Derrick

Two different guys. Like comparing Montana to Marino.

Vicks a finesse runner/thrower, Culpepper is a power runner/thrower.

Vick gets hurt. Culpepper doesn't.

Vick doesn't fumble. Culpepper does.