Thread: BEST QUARTERBACKS...

There seems to be a lot of different perspectives on who are the best quarterbacks in the NFL this season. In my opinion, most of the quaterbacks suck badly and only the good ones can stand their ground and do what a QB does, so I've compiled a list of best quaterbacks by preference on whose best. Post a reply if you think otherwise.

1) Peyton Manning
2) Daunte Culpepper :king:
3) Ben Rothleisberger
4) Donovan McNabb
5) Tom Brady
6) Mike Vick
7) Drew Brees
8. Brett Favre
9) Byron Leftwich
10) David Carr

Peyton, end of story. He has been the best the last couple seasons.

i'd put brees ahead of vick

"ItalianStallion" wrote:

Peyton, end of story. He has been the best the last couple seasons.

yo I.S. you know I respect you ALOT but to say Peyton is the better QB when all he has in site is accomplishments for himself and not the team is pushing it especially with 32 and 33 in the backfield is crazy

Vegas :blob: hey man how is it hanging :hello1: long time no post :director: GLAD to see you are alive on the planet DUDE :headbang:

You can't hide from the purple pride :happy9:

Vick does not belong in the topic at all. He is a terrible QB. he can't throw running to his right at all nor can he understand the offense or read defenses. He is 23rd in the NFL in passing yards and 24th in TD passes and has a QB rating of 83. There are 8 QB's in the league that have not even played the whole season with better numbers.
Now that being said, Vick is by far the best athelete of all QB's in the league. He leads the Falcons in rushing and rushing TD's. He is a unreal talent but not a very good QB. History shows that if he does not improve as a QB he will be like R. Cunningham, K. Stewart, or Randell EL. All great college QB's running all over teams and doing the same in the NFL until they get slowed by age or injury and then they become just ordinary. Look at Cunningham, after teams figured out how to stop Moss, Cunningham was lost. Stewart was the same , as soon as defenses stopped his running he was lost, and Randell El they just put him at WR right away. I think Vicks career will be shortened due to injury or defenses will figure out how to stop his running and then he will be just ordinary. But he is without a doubt one of the top 3 atheletes in the NFL.

I,d agree with the top 3 but maybe have Brady in at no.4.Ben Rothleisberger has really come good this season.

I wonder why Carr is on the list at all. I see nothing special from him yet.. and Farve should be no lower than forth then Brady, MacNabb,

Why isn't Kent Graham on the list.. he's one helluva quarterback :P

Why is Gus not on that list? And for the cheesers
I'm sure they are wondering about Doug Pederson.