Thread: Antoine Winfield - MMQB Defensive Player-of-the-Week - Week 16

"AWZeus" wrote:

"ultravikingfan" wrote:

No, it is not a strectch to say that about LT.
But to pick out certain players at completely different postions and compare them...you cannot.
When you say "the best defensive player of his day" you are looking at the overall impact.

Oh - and yes Kareem was 100x better.
I was using that to prove my point that these are 2 completlet different positions and hard to compare.
Unless you look at overall value to the team.

No, you can't compare the direct stats and such, because the responsibilities are different.
I suppose one measuring stick could be - who would you miss the most if he were injured for the season?
On the 2006 Vikings defense, that's clearly Winfield.

=Z=

Thank you.
I do not know why you want to argue.
You just helped me prove my point.
Maybe I was not being clear enough.

I guess I am a lightining rod for you.
;D

"ultravikingfan" wrote:

"AWZeus" wrote:

"ultravikingfan" wrote:

No, it is not a strectch to say that about LT.
But to pick out certain players at completely different postions and compare them...you cannot.
When you say "the best defensive player of his day" you are looking at the overall impact.

Oh - and yes Kareem was 100x better.
I was using that to prove my point that these are 2 completlet different positions and hard to compare.
Unless you look at overall value to the team.

No, you can't compare the direct stats and such, because the responsibilities are different.
I suppose one measuring stick could be - who would you miss the most if he were injured for the season?
On the 2006 Vikings defense, that's clearly Winfield.

=Z=

Thank you.
I do not know why you want to argue.
You just helped me prove my point.
Maybe I was not being clear enough.

I guess I am a lightining rod for you.

;D

We're not arguing.
We're agreeing and saying the same thing two different ways.

=Z=