Thread: 5 best QB for starting your NFL team. CULPEPPER not allowed

For the sake of this POSTING we are not allowed to add Daunte Culpepper.
We already have him on our team.

1.) P.Manning
2.) McNabb
3.) McNair
4.) DelHomme
5.) Brady

Notables:
Leftwich
Vick
Pennington
Favre definitely if he was 3 yrs younger and not contemplating retirement. I respect him as a player and 3 years ago he would have been in the top 2.

I'de have to say manning he is the low risk high reward kinda guy.. its partly a safe dicision but its a really good one.. i choose peyton.

"snowinapril" wrote:

For the sake of this POSTING we are not allowed to add Daunte Culpepper.
We already have him on our team.

1.) P.Manning
2.) McNabb
3.) McNair
4.) DelHomme
5.) Brady

Notables:
Leftwich
Vick
Pennington
Favre definitely if he was 3 yrs younger and not contemplating retirement. I respect him as a player and 3 years ago he would have been in the top 2.

Dan Marino :drunken:

I meant to say current QB's

The list would have been totally different if we allowed the retirees in the topic.

Yes, Marino would be a good one.

I will say my
old guy = 1.)Elway
new guys = 2.)Manning

P. Manning
B. Johnson
D. Mcnab
Kitna if he was a starter.
Mcnair

"snowinapril" wrote:

I meant to say current QB's

I was being sarcastic rook. The elder Manning of course would have to be number one. But I would take Marino over Leftwich, even today irate:

Sorry Coach Hovan won't happen again

"snowinapril" wrote:

For the sake of this POSTING we are not allowed to add Daunte Culpepper.
We already have him on our team.

1.) P.Manning
2.) McNabb
3.) McNair
4.) DelHomme
5.) Brady

Notables:
Leftwich
Vick
Pennington
Favre definitely if he was 3 yrs younger and not contemplating retirement. I respect him as a player and 3 years ago he would have been in the top 2.

(1) Brady-Look at what he has done with no WR's and no running game
(2) Mcnair-Toughest QB in the NFL
(3) Vick-all the guy does is win as a starter,and with a bad D too
(4) Manning-He struggles some in the layoffs, but give him a good D and watch out
(5) Pennington-Young, but I think he is a great leader for how young he is
(6) Mcnabb-Playmaker. He has done some amazing things with no weapons around him.

Much Luv,

I like your list.

side note:
Vick didn't make my list mainly because I would prefer the pocket pass - run sometimes. Man did you see him flip last weekend, he is on the road to an injury. He is super talented but I would have to take others above him

Del Homme is a long shot but I would be willing to take the chance on him.