trade opinions please

My Roster

QB Cutler, Delhomme
RB LT, Barber, Chester Taylor
WR Wayne, Steve Smith, Hines Ward, Santana Moss
TE McMichael, LJ Smith
K Rackers
DST Vikes(homer pick), Steelers

I have been offered Reggie Bush & Donte Stallworth for Ward and Barber. We start 3 WR's and its a standard scoring league. I am hesitent to give up such a solid WR corp. Basically I had the first pick so grabbed LT obvioulsy but when every one else went RB and QB
meanwhile there is one team that has Deion Branch as their best WR and one has Santana Moss. I went with WR since we start 3 along with one other person. Wayne Was my 2nd pick and Smith was my 3rd pick. first week at least I hands down scored the most points. behind the other team that went WR instead.
He has Holt, Chad Johnson, and Randy Moss.

Opinons are greatly appreciated.

use this:

http://www.kffl.com/static/programs/football/trade_analyzer/

In Stallworth's current situation, he's pretty much a throwaway the way things are shaping up....
So the question is, is Bushy vs. Barber worth it for what else you'd lose.... I couldn't see you starting Stallworth other than a bye-week option.

Projected points for what it is worth.
Bush, Reggie RB NO 178.0
Barber, Marion RB DAL 140.0
Ward, Hines WR PIT 136.0
Stallworth, Donte' WR NE 100.0

Tough call.
You have to look at what you "think" will happen the rest of the season.

For what it's worth I've always found it's best to go with your gut feeling rather than over-analyze.

Bush for Barber is a no brainer. Stallworth probably won't be at all consistent, so giving up Ward for him is a loser. If you have flex position this works, but if you have to play 3 wides every week it doesn't really make sense for you.

"Desertvikingfan" wrote:

Quote:

---

Bush for Barber is a no brainer. Stallworth probably won't be at all consistent, so giving up Ward for him is a loser. If you have flex position this works, but if you have to play 3 wides every week it doesn't really make sense for you.

---

I dont think barber for bush is a no brainer.Barber scored 16 td's last year and i will pick him oer bush in a heart beat

"thevikingfan" wrote:

Quote:

---

"Desertvikingfan" wrote:

Quote:

---

Bush for Barber is a no brainer. Stallworth probably won't be at all consistent, so giving up Ward for him is a loser. If you have flex position this works, but if you have to play 3 wides every week it doesn't really make sense for you.

---

I dont think barber for bush is a no brainer.Barber scored 16 td's last year and i will pick him oer bush in a heart beat

---

I agree if you don't get points per reception I'd rather have Barber and Ward.
Bush still seems to be feast or famine, MBIII looked good in that last game even though Julius Jones looked decent too.

"lakehubertviking" wrote:

Quote:

---

"thevikingfan" wrote:

Quote:

---

"Desertvikingfan" wrote:

Quote:

---

Bush for Barber is a no brainer. Stallworth probably won't be at all consistent, so giving up Ward for him is a loser. If you have flex position this works, but if you have to play 3 wides every week it doesn't really make sense for you.

---

I dont think barber for bush is a no brainer.Barber scored 16 td's last year and i will pick him oer bush in a heart beat

---

I agree if you don't get points per reception I'd rather have Barber and Ward.
Bush still seems to be feast or famine, MBIII looked good in that last game even though Julius Jones looked decent too.

---

Reggie bush had 545 rushing yards and 6 td and 749 recieving yards with 2 tds

Barber had 654 rushing yards (more than bush) along with 14 tds and he also had 196 recieving yards/ and 2 reciving tds.

so the only thing you gain with bush is 500 recieving yards and lose 8 tds

"thevikingfan" wrote:

Quote:

---

"lakehubertviking" wrote:

Quote:

---

"thevikingfan" wrote:

Quote:

---

"Desertvikingfan" wrote:

Quote:

---

Bush for Barber is a no brainer. Stallworth probably won't be at all consistent, so giving up Ward for him is a loser. If you have flex position this works, but if you have to play 3 wides every week it doesn't really make sense for you.

---

I dont think barber for bush is a no brainer.Barber scored 16 td's last year and i will pick him oer bush in a heart beat

---

I agree if you don't get points per reception I'd rather have Barber and Ward.
Bush still seems to be feast or famine, MBIII looked good in that last game even though Julius Jones looked decent too.

---

Reggie bush had 545 rushing yards and 6 td and 749 recieving yards with 2 tds

Barber had 654 rushing yards (more than bush) along with 14 tds and he also had 196 recieving yards/ and 2 reciving tds.

so the only thing you gain with bush is 500 recieving yards and lose 8 tds

---

I like Bush this year, I don't think Barber will match last year performance and I think Bush could see a lot more oppurtunities near the goal line than he did last year. Could be wrong, in FF, it wouldn't be the first time.