Thread: Carson Palmer or Matt Schaub?

Well, you read the thread title.
Should I start Carson Palmer, who has been my starter since Week 1, against the Titans' 7th-ranked pass defense?
Or should I go with my backup, Matt Schaub, who is currently benefiting from the return of Andre Johnson (as am I, BTW ;D ), going up against a Browns team that gave up 45 points to Carson Palmer's Bengals?


Edit: Oooh!
Almost forgot: I happen to be LOADED at wide receiver, so I'm thankful for the luxury of being able to ask this question: Anquan Boldin or Steve Smith?
Most people wouldn't have this problem, because they'd be starting both.
However, there's no way I'm benching Andre Johnson or Braylon Edwards this week.
Judging by recent performance, I'd be inclined to go with Boldin, as Smith has been killing me with the goose eggs he's been laying.
However, Vinny Testaverde is coming back this week, and he throws the ball his way a lot more than David "Has An Arm Like a Guy Who Just Got His Elbow Run Over By A" Carr.

(I wouldn't get too jealous, though - I drafted Shaun Alexander in the first round.
Ouch).

Carson Palmer

Go with Schaub

Okay, sounds like we've reached a consensus on the QB issue.
How about my WR dilemma?

I didn't see the edit.

Arizona is playing San Francisco, so that must mean Boldin is the answer there.

"cogitans" wrote:

I didn't see the edit.

Arizona is playing San Francisco, so that must mean Boldin is the answer there.

Yeah, but on the other hand, Cleveland's pass defense is WAY worse than SF's (which is actually ranked 9th).

"BBQ" wrote:

"cogitans" wrote:

I didn't see the edit.

Arizona is playing San Francisco, so that must mean Boldin is the answer there.

Yeah, but on the other hand, Cleveland's pass defense is WAY worse than SF's (which is actually ranked 9th).

Then you must just go with your gut.

Testaverde won't play today though.

"V" wrote:

Matt Schaub

good call :

Sorry

"cogitans" wrote:

Sorry

Shit happens ;D