Thread: Put the following QB's in order...

in your opinion, from best to worst

Jay Cutler
Tony Romo
Matt Schaub
Josh Freeman

Thanks for your assistance in probably proving my friend wrong.

That's tough actually.

None of them have proven anything in the clutch, so I'd have to go by numbers alone. In that case:

Romo
Schaub
Cutler
Freeman

If Freeman repeats this years performance twice more he'll be on top of that list, but for now he's last.

Originally Posted by "Mr Anderson" #1089236

That's tough actually.

None of them have proven anything in the clutch, so I'd have to go by numbers alone. In that case:

Romo
Schaub
Cutler
Freeman

If Freeman repeats this years performance twice more he'll be on top of that list, but for now he's last.

Yeah ... I agree that these guys all have a lot to prove. But Cutler at least has one playoff victory so I put him above Schaub.

I would rank em:
Romo
Cutler
Schaub
Freeman

But if I could have any one of them as my QB ... it would be Freeman

Originally Posted by "Tad7" #1089235

in your opinion, from best to worst

Jay Cutler
Tony Romo
Matt Schaub
Josh Freeman

Thanks for your assistance in probably proving my friend wrong.

Best to worst really is all relative in my book. Talent wise?
Cutler
Romo
Schaub (he has AJ who could make anyone look like a superstar)
Freeman

Devlopment wise?
Romo
Schaub
Cutler
Freeman

Who I would want on my team right now?
Freeman
Schaub
Romo
Cutler

Cutler last in every category. I would take all 3 of them before him.

Originally Posted by "midgensa" #1089237

But if I could have any one of them as my QB ... it would be Freeman

You are wise beyond your years my friend.

If I was to rank them, though, I would go like this....


Jay Cutler - Alot of fans hack on him because of the INT's and how he acts (or doesn't act) on the field. I for one look at the OL he had in front of him the last 2 years, the WR's he has had and mix in the lack of a running game, and could make a pretty good case that he kindof carries the Bores offense.

For some that are looking for a cat to prove something, I offer that up there.

Josh Freeman - I have watched him close the last 2 years. Very fun to watch play the game. Like Cutler, he has a team that is growing around him and expect to see him take the next step next year as that group matures around him.

On a side note, Tampa fans are being pretty patient with him, unlike some fans I know. :P

Matt Schaub - He's had alot of help around him. Not sure why that team hasn't been able to get over the hump.

Tony Romo - I wouldn't have this cat on my roster even as a backup. Anyone who listens to coaches should remember what the Tuna said about him. So far, he has been right.

Originally Posted by "Marrdro" #1089376

Originally Posted by "midgensa" #1089237

But if I could have any one of them as my QB ... it would be Freeman

You are wise beyond your years my friend.

If I was to rank them, though, I would go like this....


Jay Cutler - Alot of fans hack on him because of the INT's and how he acts (or doesn't act) on the field. I for one look at the OL he had in front of him the last 2 years, the WR's he has had and mix in the lack of a running game, and could make a pretty good case that he kindof carries the Bores offense.

For some that are looking for a cat to prove something, I offer that up there.

Josh Freeman - I have watched him close the last 2 years. Very fun to watch play the game. Like Cutler, he has a team that is growing around him and expect to see him take the next step next year as that group matures around him.

On a side note, Tampa fans are being pretty patient with him, unlike some fans I know. :P

Matt Schaub - He's had alot of help around him. Not sure why that team hasn't been able to get over the hump.

Tony Romo - I wouldn't have this cat on my roster even as a backup. Anyone who listens to coaches should remember what the Tuna said about him. So far, he has been right.

The Texans were 9th in points scored, but 29th in points given up. Chances are, you won't get into the play-offs like that.

Freeman is so young, but has so much potential. The way he's already leading 4th quarter comebacks is very impressive. I'd like him as my QB of the future, as well.

I like Tony Romo a lot. I think he gets one heck of a raw deal for the way he produces. He's actually played in 4 play-off games and performed great in two of them. He won one. For some reason, though, those get forgotten and people rather talk about how he hasn't been to the NFCCG and that he fumbled on the PAT.

Cutler is one of those guys who has the potential to throw for a lot of yards in a season and make a lot of plays... But he makes way too many mistakes, as well. Even in his best season he threw for 25 TDs to 18 Ints. His technique is all over the place, as well. I mean, he's been in the league for all these years. You can't tell me they haven't tried to fix that. Yet, he either doesn't listen or just doesn't get it.

Matt Schaub was carrying that team last year and playing catch-up, passing football for most of this year, as well. He might have Andre Johnson, but so did David Carr. AJ's a great weapon, but he doesn't make a QB all by himself. I think that, he's maybe the most underrated QB in the game because of the way his team performs.

Right now.

Matt Schaub
Tony Romo
Josh Freeman
Jay Cutler

Starting a franchise.

Josh Freeman
Matt Schaub
Tony Romo
Jay Cutler

Originally Posted by "Rockmolder" #1089394

Originally Posted by "Marrdro" #1089376

Originally Posted by "midgensa" #1089237

But if I could have any one of them as my QB ... it would be Freeman

You are wise beyond your years my friend.

If I was to rank them, though, I would go like this....


Jay Cutler - Alot of fans hack on him because of the INT's and how he acts (or doesn't act) on the field. I for one look at the OL he had in front of him the last 2 years, the WR's he has had and mix in the lack of a running game, and could make a pretty good case that he kindof carries the Bores offense.

For some that are looking for a cat to prove something, I offer that up there.

Josh Freeman - I have watched him close the last 2 years. Very fun to watch play the game. Like Cutler, he has a team that is growing around him and expect to see him take the next step next year as that group matures around him.

On a side note, Tampa fans are being pretty patient with him, unlike some fans I know. :P

Matt Schaub - He's had alot of help around him. Not sure why that team hasn't been able to get over the hump.

Tony Romo - I wouldn't have this cat on my roster even as a backup. Anyone who listens to coaches should remember what the Tuna said about him. So far, he has been right.

The Texans were 9th in points scored, but 29th in points given up. Chances are, you won't get into the play-offs like that.

Freeman is so young, but has so much potential. The way he's already leading 4th quarter comebacks is very impressive. I'd like him as my QB of the future, as well.

I like Tony Romo a lot. I think he gets one heck of a raw deal for the way he produces. He's actually played in 4 play-off games and performed great in two of them. He won one. For some reason, though, those get forgotten and people rather talk about how he hasn't been to the NFCCG and that he fumbled on the PAT.

Cutler is one of those guys who has the potential to throw for a lot of yards in a season and make a lot of plays... But he makes way too many mistakes, as well. Even in his best season he threw for 25 TDs to 18 Ints. His technique is all over the place, as well. I mean, he's been in the league for all these years. You can't tell me they haven't tried to fix that. Yet, he either doesn't listen or just doesn't get it.

Matt Schaub was carrying that team last year and playing catch-up, passing football for most of this year, as well. He might have Andre Johnson, but so did David Carr. AJ's a great weapon, but he doesn't make a QB all by himself. I think that, he's maybe the most underrated QB in the game because of the way his team performs.

Right now.

Matt Schaub
Tony Romo
Josh Freeman
Jay Cutler

Starting a franchise.

Josh Freeman
Matt Schaub
Tony Romo
Jay Cutler

Not bad my friend, although, I think you give Romo to much credit. Cat has all the weapons around him. He should do better than he does.

I just cant help but wonder what the Texans would be like if they had ANY defense what so ever. I mean they allowed Tim Tebow back from a 27 point deficit.

Here is my rating:

Schaub-injury suceptible and always pressing to make a play
Freeman-making others good around him while controlling the ball
Cutler-tons of talent, he just needs that line to play consistently
Romo-too much talent/distractions around him on and off the field....