Thread: Joey Sunshine's Top 5 WRs in the NFL

Can we break Joey Sunshine's other leg?

Why don't they pay Joey Sunshine to keep his trap shut?
He is the perfect example of someone that was a good NFL player and a lousy commentator.

"PurplePeopleEaters" wrote:

"Mr" wrote:

I would not put Moss top 5 simply because of his production over the past two years.

He started out really hot in Oakland, but then he was injured, and just had no motivation to play hard and risk injuring himself again, that's my take on what happened.

Talent wise I can't compare any of those guys to Randy Moss, but in terms of production over the past two years they are better.

But if it were the school yard, and I had those 5 lined up in front of me I'd take Moss first pick every single time, and most of you would also.

With those lined up in the schoolyard, I would take Steve Smith, Chad Johnson, and Marvin Harrison every time over Moss.

So you're telling me you'd take the smaller, slower receiver, with lesser hands and half the big play ability?

Moss is/was(we'll see if he's traded if it is still "is") head and shoulders above these guys in terms of talent, athleticism, and just raw ability, I don't think there is any doubt about that.


And Zeus, I agree with you, Torry Holt should be #1 IMO.

"Mr" wrote:

"PurplePeopleEaters" wrote:

"Mr" wrote:

I would not put Moss top 5 simply because of his production over the past two years.

He started out really hot in Oakland, but then he was injured, and just had no motivation to play hard and risk injuring himself again, that's my take on what happened.

Talent wise I can't compare any of those guys to Randy Moss, but in terms of production over the past two years they are better.

But if it were the school yard, and I had those 5 lined up in front of me I'd take Moss first pick every single time, and most of you would also.

With those lined up in the schoolyard, I would take Steve Smith, Chad Johnson, and Marvin Harrison every time over Moss.

So you're telling me you'd take the smaller, slower receiver, with lesser hands and half the big play ability?

Moss is/was(we'll see if he's traded if it is still "is") head and shoulders above these guys in terms of talent, athleticism, and just raw ability, I don't think there is any doubt about that.


And Zeus, I agree with you, Torry Holt should be #1 IMO.

All of them are bigger playmakers than moss at this day and age. Face it, moss is past his prime and those 3 are better (plus holt).

Three years ago Moss would have been all over that list. Now he can hardly make the cut. God, what a waste of talent.

in my mind, torry holt is undoubtedly the best receiver in the nfl..has been for the past 4 years..if he was a loudmouth or a showoff that got fined on a regular basis, or just flat out played with peyton manning, everybody would have him at the top of their lists

i had a dream about a topic like this. call me crazy i guess.

top 4 not in order:
chad johnson
torry holt
marvin harrison
steve smith

the #5 spot could be any of the following:
larry fitzgerald, santana moss, roy williams, hines ward, coles, andre johnson.

owens and randy are old and suckie.

owens is a stud, cant be stopped

1. ---roy williams -- lions
2. ---terrel owens -- cowboys
3. ---steve smith -- panthers
4. ---calvin johnson -- ????
5. --- larry fitzgerald -- cardinals

Most over rated
1. NO doubt---- Hines Ward

"nextvikingsstar" wrote:

owens is a stud, cant be stopped

1. ---roy williams -- lions
2. ---terrel owens -- cowboys
3. ---steve smith -- panthers
4. ---calvin johnson -- ????
5. --- larry fitzgerald -- cardinals

Most over rated
1. NO doubt---- Hines Ward

You and me are going to get along.

"nextvikingsstar" wrote:

owens is a stud, cant be stopped

1. ---roy williams -- lions
2. ---terrel owens -- cowboys
3. ---steve smith -- panthers
4. ---calvin johnson -- ????
5. --- larry fitzgerald -- cardinals

Most over rated
1. NO doubt---- Hines Ward

How can you have Calvin Johnson at #4 when he has never even caught a single pass in the NFL.