Thread: JaMarcus Russel shouldn't be a top five pick!

Yeah, that was my point, dexter!!

"Creep" wrote:

Yeah, that was my point, dexter!!

What was your point?
That he won't fail so he should be a top 5 pick?
Wrong.
He had a good game, has good physical attributes, and did well in recent workouts.
That doesn't guarantee success.


Russell is a top 5 projection only because teams at the top need a good QB prospect and he seems to be just that.
It has nothing to do with his near certainty of success.

Who is dexter?

Dude, you're playing both sides of the same coin...

It seems to me that most of the draft predictions that i read seem to say that quin should be the number one qb taken but the raiders will pick russel because they are poorly managed and like his arm. That leads me to believe that if the raiders don't take him he could fall a few spots. I would guess he will go between 5 and 7.

"Creep" wrote:

Dude, you're playing both sides of the same coin...

What was your point?
You implied Russell is 'guaranteed to succeed' by exclaiming he should fall in the top 5; i.e. 'WTHN?'.

I am asking for your justification and you are avoiding replying with his stats, or other points to substantiate your claim.

Sincerely,

Poindexter

Yeah, I said "Why the hell not"????
Where was Montana picked?? Torretta?? T. JACKSON????UMMMM Kurt
Warner?? ROMO???To say he is NOT a top 5 is assinine!!!BUT,,,,with caution 'cause ya never really know...Phil Simms..Little guy from a little school( Moorehead State)
Actually started off as a wuss in the league....Hopping all down the field after smackinhid hand on a helmet. But became known as a top notch QB...And thought of one of the the toughest to ever play the game....

THAT was the point( and ya got he dexter part,..good) BE CAREFUL...I would rather have Quinn,( just seems safer..A smart, safe play guy that will get ya the yards,...Russel, may be looked at as a big play guy,...but
CRAP,...WHAT PROMISE!!)

idk, i'd love to have him (russel that is). he immediately enters the NFL and has the strongest arm in the league

"tjohnson" wrote:

idk, i'd love to have him (russel that is). he immediately enters the NFL and has the strongest arm in the league

Yeah because everyone knows all you need to be successfull in the NFL as a QB is a strong arm.

"davike" wrote:

"tjohnson" wrote:

idk, i'd love to have him (russel that is). he immediately enters the NFL and has the strongest arm in the league

Yeah because everyone knows all you need to be successfull in the NFL as a QB is a strong arm.

It worked for Culpe.... uh, ...never mind.

"Purplexing" wrote:

"davike" wrote:

"tjohnson" wrote:

idk, i'd love to have him (russel that is). he immediately enters the NFL and has the strongest arm in the league

Yeah because everyone knows all you need to be successfull in the NFL as a QB is a strong arm.

It worked for Culpe.... uh, ...never mind.

Also Aaron Brooks.