Sorry if this is not warranting a new thread, but, it is slow nowadays. After watching the game against the Giants and Bucs, a bit hard I have to admit. How bad did Garcia look out there. He looked pretty lost and confused most of the game. Would he have done better leading the Vikes this year? With our OL and WR situations, I'm not sure he would have been as productive as many thought. It seems to me that TJ hasn't looked that much worse than Garcia did that game. Both teams played the G-men (witht the same starters on D), and the outcomes were different. Go ahead and rip away if you like.
What you have to remember is the Vikings would have faced a lot less pressure if Garcia were the starter.
Defenses would have had to play more honest, would have been a lot less blitzes.
We'd have seen more traditional cover 2 type defenses, play action would have been more effective, and a veteran QB would have really shown his merit.
Few QBs look good under pressure and unfortunately TJack didn't make the D pay often enough for them to turn down the pressure.