Thread: Brady overrated?

http://sportsillustrated.cnn.com/si_blogs/nfl/huddle_up/2006/2006/10/is-brady-overrated.html

This is IMO a stupid article they actually put payton manning in the top 7 of overated player.Plus brady is definatly not overrated.I think he is one of the best QBs in the league.
Thoughts?

I've heard the Brady being overrated charges over and over from the Dolphins fans.
I don't buy it.
They guy can manage the game.

Brady IS a very good QB...one of the best ever...NOT!

Without that defense, he doesn't get even ONE ring!

"Ovarated"

Term dat be used by da media to counter otha media in the ovawhelmin' endless talk.

20+ yeahrs ago I dont be 'membrin so many playas bein "ovarated"

I say the sports columnists who nevar played ball be ovarated. I neva herd of Andrew Perloff, but I say he be ovarated.

you GOTTA be kidding me..........

how is Brady overrated? is is the fact that he was the youngest QB to win a Super Bowl? is it the fact that he's won 3 championships? is it the fact that he stepped in for an injured Drew Bledsoe, and LED a team to one of the greatest upsets in football history against the Rams? is it the fact he's leading the Patriots to a 5-1 record this year with a receiving corps led by..........um, whats his name.................RECHE CALDWELL??!!

please, i'll argue this point ALL day

and cajun, cmon, cant you ever acknowledge ANY boston-area athlete as being sucessful??

you want overatted, lets talk about manning. the Greatest QB in the league can't bring his team to a Super bowl, let alone win one. If defense is so important is such a big factor in a QB's reputation (still don't understand that argument) why didn't he win last year, yet still considered the best? he's surrounded by pro bowlers, but has NEVER led his team to a championship.

tom brady overrated, f@ck that

I think both manning and brady are great QB's, I dont know how a fan base calling brad johnson a savior can call any QB overrated.
I would take either one in a heartbeat especially over johnson.
Its either smoots fault or the media's fault johnson is not on that list as being a top QB

I agree, Tom Brady is the furthest thing from overrated I have seen in a QB.. You want overrated? Try Daunte Culpepper, Ben Rothlesberger, and even Brett Favre.. Rothlesberger, and Favre may have won Super Bowls, but both of them somebitches are very overrated... Tom Brady is a legitimate leader at QB.. He has poise, and a calmness about him that many QB's don't.. I would take Brady on my team anyday of the week..

"cajunvike" wrote:

Brady IS a very good QB...one of the best ever...NOT!

Without that defense, he doesn't get even ONE ring!

That is the same for johnson.
Brady has more ability though

"VikesfaninWis" wrote:

I agree, Tom Brady is the furthest thing from overrated I have seen in a QB.. You want overrated? Try Daunte Culpepper, Ben Rothlesberger, and even Brett Favre.. Rothlesberger, and Favre may have won Super Bowls, but both of them somebitches are very overrated... Tom Brady is a legitimate leader at QB.. He has poise, and a calmness about him that many QB's don't.. I would take Brady on my team anyday of the week..

I dont care for farve but he is not overrated, 3 MVP's is not overrated.
He could be top 5 of all time when he is done.

Speaking of farve, were are all the packer fans this year, this is the worst i have seen in regards to packer fans on this site.
I guess the orkin man did his job finally

"PurpleRide" wrote:

I think both manning and brady are great QB's, I dont know how a fan base calling brad johnson a savior can call any QB overrated.
I would take either one in a heartbeat especially over johnson.
Its either smoots fault or the media's fault johnson is not on that list as being a top QB

You forgot about the fans that think the media is out to get them.
Your big three:

1. BJ.
2. Smoot
3. Fans and Media